Very sad news for the Tablet PC community arrived today. A man I was proud to recognize as a fellow enthusiast and insightful thinker, Loren Heiny, passed away after years of battling cancer. I typed out my thoughts earlier to share with the GottaBeMobile community, but the only proper way for me to honor Loren is in ink.
As a software developer, he strived to improve the Tablet PC experience, such as with his InkGestures software, and pushed it across platforms, as seen with his inking in Firefox experiments. He never gave up on the platform, and looking back at some of the things I wrote about him, it's amazing how insightful he was about the industry and where it was going. It is a terrible shame he won't be with us to enjoy the next generation of tablets to follow, which we surely saw coming.
[We never met in person, something I regret, but I felt a real kinship with Loren. Our perspectives on the tablet scene were very parallel. We never collaborated on anything, but time and again, we came to the same conclusions even when coming from different directions. On the odd occasion when I disagreed with him, his logic still proved solid and usually superior. How insightful was he? He claimed the iPhone platform was moving us toward a new generation of tablets and that a big iPod touch would prove a huge success -- that was two years ago. It is unfortunate he was only able to see these first steps come to fruition and won’t be here for the true next-gen Tablet PCs he dreamed would follow. Loren was truly a thinker and visionary. He and his beautiful thoughts will be missed.] [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text
In addition Malorkus at the Buzz has released updates for GeckoTIP and Grab & Drag, two extensions that make FF extremely pen-friendly.
Between these extensions and All-in-One gestures, Firefox is so much easier to use with a pen than IE. Once ink is added, it might as well come pre-installed on Tablet PCs and Ultramobs (UMPCs).
Anyone else think Loren Heiny, Josh Einstein and InkEnable should get together Sentai style and form the "Ink Enabler Super Team"? Between TEO, InkGestures, and now TipX, not to mention Loren's work with IE & PowerPoint, these guys are delivering sensational ink options for Microsoft Office. If they got together to form the Voltron of Office Ink, they could be the invincible champion of the inkiverse (or some such).
Perhaps Bill Gates, being the charitable tablet supporter that he is, could cut them a small check to get started, no-strings grant of a fraction of a percent of his net worth, so they can focus on software, not on money. Let's face it, Bill: these guys are making your software and ideal form factor even better. Let's all spread the word and convince Mr. Gates to add the "Office Ink Co-op" to his list of charities. [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text
Loren Heiny (http://journals.tuxreports.com/lch/archives/004366.html) suggests that Steve Ballmer could step up as the top Tablet PC advocate as Bill Gates steps down from running Microsoft. He suggests that Steve should forget a typed blog and go with a photo/ink blog because,
I seem to have kicked off a combination of hope (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2009/05/04/the-tablet-pc-has-another-competitor-in-universities-the-kindle-dx/) and concern (http://www.gottabemobile.com/2009/05/05/ereaders-to-drive-tablet-pc-further-into-a-niche/) for the future of Tablet PCs today when I noted students carrying around the reportedly bigger Kindle DX (http://www.gottabemobile.com/2009/05/05/that-larger-amazon-kindle-is-going-to-be-used-for-textbooks/) will be disinclined to carry a Tablet PC along with it.
The concern for me is that it will dampen enthusiasm for the Tablet PC. If a student has all their textbooks on an electronic reader that allow annotations, why bother carrying a second tablet device for note-taking? It almost adds back in the costs, weight, and bulk shed by using digital books.
There are benefits to such a combo, and I'd certainly be inclined to try it. But for most people, it would be a third device, after a multi-function phone, of limited added value relative to the costs.
On the other hand, the Kindle DX is yet another tablet device at a time Loren Heiny is calling the Year of the Slate (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2009/05/04/this-is-the-year-of-the-slate/). Certainly the enthusiasm for single-piece computing devices is there. So that's gotta be good for Tablet PCs, right?
Well, yes and no. See, the market is growing around appliance-type slates, devices designed for particular purposes. No matter how versatile devices like the iPhone or Crunchpad become, they are still built with key activities in mind. The Tablet PC, however, has always been a general computing device, albeit one with expanded functionality for mobility. Ironically, the specialized slates are going mainstream, while the general purpose tablet remains niche.
Thus, the Tablet PC is in danger of being squeezed further out of the mainstream market by specialty slates. If it stays true to its GP roots, it risks extinction. If it evolves into more specialized forms, extinction is guaranteed. Why? Because one of a Tablet PC's defining features is that it is a general computing device. Lose that and the category ceases to be. Either way, I predict we will see even less activity in the Tablet PC market for the foreseeable future.
However, my hope is that the specialty slates will ultimately instill in users a desire for tablet functionality in their general computing devices, culminating in a Tablet PC renaissance. Far fetched? Maybe, but the path is there. [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text
Okay, I knew there would be disagreement over my attempt to send some "best medicine" (http://sumocat.blogspot.com/2007/12/holy-s-dont-quit-facebook.html) Marc Orchant's way and I'm glad someone verbalized it (although I have to admit that I frequently disagree with Rob, despite my respect for his opinions). But then I read Loren Heiny's latest entry on Incremental Blogger (http://journals.tuxreports.com/lch/archives/004546.html) and felt the slap of irony.
Do I have to point out the pattern I perceive? Must I describe the irony despite the inappropriate humor it entails? No, I don't. But at the same time, this is where I present my perspective. Not sharing what I perceive defeats the point of the blog, and I'm not sorry to say my perspective is non-standard.
However, I will exercise restraint on this one and not connect the dots, not because it is in poor taste (and the way I connected the dots, it really is), but rather because it would make light of a tough situation for the sake of making light of it, as opposed to being a personalized expression of support.
Or maybe I'm just pissed that the universe is throwing another inappropriate punchline at me and expecting me to jump on it. Either way, I'm not describing the pattern this time, though I can't do anything about perceiving it.
Wow! Today, Apple announced the software development kit for the iPhone (http://developer.apple.com/iphone/program/), and once again they showed us the right way to do things.
The kit itself is the usual fare, giving developers the tools they need to build applications for the iPhone. The special stuff is the support they're offering those developers.
First, they announced the App Store, where developers can sell or give away their wares. Second, they announced venture capital to give developers the funding they need to launch their new apps. The amount of that capital? $100 million!
This is big news, and I'm not alone in wondering why Microsoft has yet to show similar support to the Tablet PC or UMPC form factors. Would the TPC be considered "niche" or "failed" if Microsoft had given it similar support? Would the UMPC still be hunting for a market?
When Dell finally entered the Tablet PC market, they did so under the pretext of fixing all the frustrations of us tablet users. They punctuated their point with web videos showing other tablets getting beaten tike piñatas (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rMYzBT0Lts) or run though table saws (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J92EhE2DIdo) by frustrated users. They set the bar pretty high, so I wasn't really expecting them to deliver (and the price point pretty much killed my interest). However, I am really surprised that not one, but two, prominent tableteers are openly questioning if Dell should recall their Latitude XT Tablet PC.
The XT is the first and only Tablet PC to feature a multi-touch capable digitizer, similar to the iPhone's. I say "capable" because it still lacks the software to really take advantage of it. And, according to Rob Bushway (http://www.gottabemobile.com/2008/10/20/dell-and-n-trig-ive-had-it/) and Loren Heiny (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2008/10/20/dell-latitude-xt-tablet-pc-time-for-a-recall/), it has so many other issues that Dell should consider a recall. Ouch.
Oh well. Even through I've never used an XT, I must admit I've never quite forgiven Dell for their displays of tablet destruction. Maybe next time they won't bash the competition (literally) before proving they won't be just as bad or, as is being claimed, worse. [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text
The rumor mill is churning out the speculation on a Mac Tablet again, and the expectations are higher than ever.
First, Apple has let it be known they are planning a "product transition" (http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/21/an-itease-something-cool-and-cheap-from-apple/) and have a lot of new stuff in the pipeline. By "new" it is generally assumed they mean tablets because that would be the next logical step for them.
Second, Mike Arrington (http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/07/21/we-want-a-dead-simple-web-tablet-help-us-build-it/) announces that he wants a web tablet, which stirs up excitement over the form factor. Rob Bushway (http://www.gottabemobile.com/Is+TechCrunch+For+Real+About+The+Web+Tablet+I+Dont+Think+So+And+Heres+Why.aspx), however, is skeptical, pondering if this might be Arrington's way of spilling the secret of an Apple tablet without actually saying it.
Third, check out this quote from a previously accurate informant for MacDailyNews (http://www.macdailynews.com/index.php/weblog/comments/rumor_apples_secret_product_is_macbook_touch/): [Think MacBook screen, possibly a bit smaller, in glass with iPhone-like, but fuller-featured Multi-Touch. Gesture library. Full Mac OS X. This is why they bought P.A. Semi. Possibly with Immersion's haptic tech. Slot-loading SuperDrive. Accelerometer. GPS. Pretty expensive to produce initially, but sold at "low" price that will reduce margins. Apple wants to move these babies. And move they will. This is some sick shit. App Store-compatible, able to run Mac apps, too. By October at the latest]
All that sounds extremely exciting. but as cool as a Macbook touch would be, does Apple have a compelling reason to launch such a product? Absolutely - iPhone apps.
Aside from the obvious cool factor of running iPhone apps on a full slate computer, the ability to build and test these apps on one machine would be tremendously useful for app developers. Seems like too small a market segment to bother targeting, except, as Windows has shown, the operating system with the most applications wins.
As Loren Heiny states directly (good luck to him (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2008/07/20/more-cancer-challenges-ahead/), BTW), The iPhone is the most interesting platform (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2008/07/20/the-iphone-is-the-most-interesting-platform/), and I agree: the device itself is incentive enough to attract developers. Add to that a dedicated venture capital fund and a distribution system built into one of the world's biggest media retailers. If Apple topped that off with a machine developers could use to build apps and test their interaction with multi-touch, GPs and accelerometer, they could dominate the mobile market through sheer volume of developers. Furthermore, having all those developers working in Mac OS X building apps for iPhone OS X should help to bring more apps to Mac, a persistent weak point for them.
This is, of course, all speculation, but the pieces are in place for Apple to cement their position in the mobile app market by releasing a product no one else can match. Those who can match the hardware, like Dell, don't have the software. Those who must fight Apple in the mobile app market, like Nokia, don't build computers. If Apple launches a tablet that hits those rumored features, it will give them a subtle but serious advantage. [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text
Fellow Tablet PC enthusiast, blogger, and thinker Loren Heiny has made some waves lately with his thoughts regarding tablets and the iPhone. As usual, I find I must bow to his logic. But it's one thing to say I agree with someone; it's another to back it up with history.
From Incremental Blogger: A Tablet PC desktop keyboard (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2008/08/11/a-tablet-pc-friendly-desktop-keyboard/): [sketch of keyboard with touchpad] + ["...the digitizer surface would be multi-touch..."]
From my blog: About the Mac Tablet speculation... (http://sumocat.blogspot.com/2007/08/about-mac-tablet-speculation.html) ["...multi-touch...multi-touch..."] + ["...keyboards with touchpads..."]
From Incremental Blogger: Is the end of the Tablet PC era in sight (http://www.lorenheiny.com/2008/08/09/is-the-end-of-the-tablet-pc-era-in-sight/): ["...I think we’re on the cusp of a new generation of Tablets. The iPhone being the first of them..."]
From my blog: Apple officially kicks everyone's ass (http://sumocat.blogspot.com/2007/01/apple-officially-kicks-everyones-ass.html): ["Oh, one more thing, anyone else look at this iPhone and see a small Tablet PC?"]
Different circumstances, but it's pretty clear we're looking in the same direction. Not sure if that makes us "great minds", but I like the way we're thinking. [+/-] Hide/Show Text [+/-] Hide/Show Text